Enjoy a 4.8-star stay at Silver Horseshoe Inn in St Anthony, ID. Features free Wi-Fi, breakfast, parking, restaurant, and easy access to nearby attractions.
Visitors consistently highlight the friendly service, comfortable and spacious rooms, and unique old-west ambiance. The location offers value near Yellowstone, with convenient nearby attractions and helpful amenities.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Located in the heart of St. Anthony, Idaho, Silver Horseshoe Inn provides a comfortable base for travelers exploring the area. The property blends a historic charm with modern updates, offering a distinctive “old west” style decor that guests have noted as both thoughtfully designed and inviting. Spacious suites and studios feature air conditioning, kitchens in some rooms, and amenities such as free Wi-Fi and complimentary breakfast, catering well to extended-stay guests and families.
The inn includes on-site dining options with a restaurant and bar, while guests can also access a fitness center and free parking. Although the property is smoke-free and not pet-friendly, it remains a practical choice for those seeking a quiet, well-maintained environment with personalized service. Guest reviews often highlight the welcoming and accommodating staff, as well as the cleanliness and comfort of the accommodations.
Conveniently situated near attractions like Idaho's Haunted Hospital, Teton Dam, and the Legacy Flight Museum, the inn is well placed for sightseeing and recreational activities. It is also accessible from several regional airports, including Idaho Falls Regional Airport and Jackson Hole Airport, which are within reasonable driving distances.
The Silver Horseshoe Inn appeals to visitors prioritizing comfort and location over luxury amenities such as pools or pet accommodations. It is particularly suited for travelers who appreciate a quieter setting with practical facilities, including laundry services, and those planning extended stays or family visits. The property’s blend of historic character with modern conveniences contributes to its strong rating and positive guest feedback.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
We spent one night at the Silver Horseshoe Inn while traveling. We loved it. The service was welcoming, friendly, and fun. The place itself is impeccably clean, extremely thoughtfully decorated. We stayed in the suite, which was very comfortable, and felt like an historic place. This was the only time, of hundreds of hotel stays, that I have ever photographed a room as we were leaving. It is charming and special.
THIS HOTEL IS AWESOME!!! The suites are huge and decorated very cool. The beds were extremely comfortable & the rooms were very clean. We played pool in the saloon...very fun place to stay. The owners are wonderful & very friendly. We will definitely stay there again. Highly recommend!!!
After a few days in Yellowstone & Grand Tetons this hotel was a great place to rest our heads & do some laundry for the next leg of our trip. Hotel staff was very personable & accommodating. Rooms were updated, spacious & clean. Would stay again!
What a pleasant surprise! The Silver Horseshoe Inn far exceeded our expectations. Tastefully remodeled with great furnishings and amenities, our room was what I’d call the best of both Airbnb and hotel worlds. Comfy queen bed and couch, fully-stocked kitchen, desk, space heater, amazing fridge, extra linens, plenty of toiletries. Bunk beds for kids (extra $15/pp). And did I mention the included breakfast (in the fridge & freezer)? The two of us could have made four meals from just that. The amenities really included anything one might need. The owner was very friendly and helpful, offering advice on local eateries, etc. Starting about Idaho Falls, lodging prices go up the closer you get to Yellowstone. Considering this is only 70 miles from the park, I’d consider it a best value. We would stay here again in a heartbeat.
We stopped for a night on our way from Wyoming to Montana to check out Idaho. Charming hotel, clean, remodeled, large spacious rooms, free to do our laundry at no charge. We stopped in this area to check out the sand dunes. Front desk staff was a pleasure. Only 12 rooms so very quiet. I would recommend & stay here again!
Loved staying here! The staff was so friendly and went out of their way to make sure we were comfortable. We loved the “old west” style. Having breakfast in the fridge in your room available was so nice.
Just stayed at this little cute, cozy hotel in St. Anthony , ID. The rooms are really nice and updated and the atmosphere is excellent. I can't wait to see what the whole property looks like as they complete the remodel. Definitely coming back in future.
What a cozy spot to stay at. We stayed in one of the studios and it had pretty much everything we needed. Their restaurant isn’t open yet, so they hooked us up with all the breakfast stuff to make our own breakfast (nice touch with the little orange juices). The bed was super comfy, and we slept really well. If you're looking for a unique place to stay, go ahead and book a room here. The owner was really friendly and we had a great chat about hunting. We’ll definitely stay here again next time we’re passing through town.
Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Idaho. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
330 reviews 400 Airport Rd, Rexburg, ID 83440, United States
111 reviews 2266 E 600 N, St Anthony, ID 83445, United States
136 reviews Newdale, ID 83436, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Relax at Seaside All Suites Hotel in Miami Beach with outdoor pool, free WiFi, and LGBTQ+ friendly stays. Close to North Beach an...
Stay at Courtyard by Marriott Owensboro, a 4.3star hotel with dining, indoor pool, and free WiFi, near Bluegrass Music Hall and S...
Stay at Cedar Lodge and Settlement in Wisconsin Dells. Enjoy riverside log cabins, free water park passes, outdoor pool, free park...
Bright studios with kitchenettes, indoor pool, and BBQ area near Swan Lake Iris Gardens. LGBTQ+ friendly hotel off US348 in Sumte...
Stay at White Sands Motel in Alamogordo, NM with free WiFi, breakfast, and parking. Rated 4.6 from 321 reviews. Close to White Sa...
Enjoy free breakfast, outdoor pool, and gym at Country Inn & Suites by Radisson in Indianapolis East. Near Children's Museum, Zoo ...
Experience SōLSTAY Lodging & Marina in Sandusky, OH with free WiFi, hot tub, and marina access. Near Cedar Point and Top Thrill 2...
Relax in casual suites with private balconies, full kitchens, and free beach access. Walk to Ocean City Boardwalk & enjoy indoor p...
Sands Inn & Kitchen Suites offers comfortable extended stay lodging in Woodward, OK. Rated 4 with 284 reviews, LGBTQ+ friendly, id...
Stay at Comfort Suites Port Wentworth Savannah North with indoor pool, free breakfast, and whirlpool tubs. Close to Savannah Air...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
